In comments submitted to the Ministry of Agriculture and Environment on draft amendments to the Law on Environmental Protection and related draft decrees and circulars, the Vietnam Chamber of Commerce and Industry (VCCI) said a 15% mandatory recycling rate for mobile phones and glass packaging does not reflect market conditions.
Citing 10 years of data from Vietnam Recycles, a non-profit PRO programme directly funded and officially operated in Vietnam by Apple and HP, VCCI said the actual collection rate for mobile phones had never exceeded 1%. The rate for laptops and tablets was below 3%. People often keep old phones, give them to relatives or resell them, so these devices generally do not enter the ordinary waste stream.
VCCI considers a 15% mobile phone recycling target unattainable and said it could cause most technology companies to become accidental law violators. For glass packaging, it proposed lowering the mandatory rate to 4–6%.
A 2024 EEPSEA survey found that only 6% of scrap dealers and 8% of waste pickers in Vietnam collect glass because of its low economic value, heavy weight and high transport costs. A report by the PRO Vietnam Alliance and beverage companies found that collecting coloured glass bottles costs up to VND25,000 per kilogram, 12 times the current fund contribution of about VND2,000 per kilogram. Actual collection was around 6%.
VCCI said imposing a 15% glass target would create a huge compliance cost burden for food and beverage manufacturers.
A three-year review mechanism
VCCI said automatically raising recycling rates from 2026 to 2034 would not fit an adaptive management approach because Vietnam’s domestic recycling market is still at an early stage. In the European Union, Singapore and South Korea, authorities generally set one collection target for each three-year cycle and assess market capacity before changing it.
The draft does not clearly distinguish short-life consumer electronics from commercial refrigeration equipment and large industrial central air-conditioning systems. These products have service lives of 10–30 years, are recorded as fixed assets and are disposed of through controlled industrial procedures.
VCCI proposed setting a mandatory rate only for 2026–2028, removing the automatic nine-year increase schedule and reassessing capacity after each three-year cycle. It also proposed allowing collection above the target for office equipment and computers to offset a shortfall for mobile phones within the same electronic equipment group, and separately classifying long-life refrigeration, industrial and commercial electronic equipment with suitable recycling rates and procedures.
Sources: Thanh Niên


