Banhbao TV

Vietnamese deputy warns one company may keep two sets of accounting books

Deputy Pham Trong Nhan said one Vietnamese company may submit different financial reports to tax authorities and banks, showing losses in one case and stronger finances in the other.

Deputy Pham Trong Nhan speaks at Vietnam's National Assembly.
Photo: Thanh Niên

Deputy Pham Trong Nhan said one Vietnamese company may submit different financial reports to tax authorities and banks, showing losses in one case and stronger finances in the other.

On November 13, the National Assembly discussed amendments to accounting and independent-auditing laws, along with tax issues involving power BOT projects backed by government guarantees.

Nhan said he had received offers for reports prepared to help companies obtain bank loans while showing the lowest possible tax payments. One company could therefore have one report for tax authorities and another for a bank in the same year, although the accounting law prohibits the practice.

The draft amendments would ban accounting-service providers from colluding with clients to certify false figures. Nhan said detection remains difficult because the two versions are not effectively compared.

A company may report little profit or a loss to tax authorities while appearing financially healthy to a bank. The tax authority also reported companies running two parallel accounting systems and asked software providers for customer lists.

Nhan proposed a database of annual financial reports, bank access for comparison with a company's consent, and clear responsibility for the person signing a report. He also proposed banning software that changes records without leaving a trace or runs two accounting systems for one period.

Deputy calls for strict sanctions

Deputy Pham Van Hoa said accountants can face pressure from business owners and be ordered to hide books or revenue and falsify tax documents. He called for strict sanctions.

Finance Minister Ngo Van Tuan speaks at Vietnam's National Assembly.

Finance Minister Ngo Van Tuan said demand for accounting services was increasing. Vietnam has about 800,000 operating companies, around 12,500 using accounting services. About 2,500 accountants hold certificates, but slightly more than 500 provide services. Of 129 registered accounting-service companies, 118 were active.

Authorities will review professional requirements, prohibited conduct and conflict-of-interest rules to improve the law and accounting services.

Sources: Thanh Niên